Skip to main content
20 cards ranked

Best credit card to use at Misfits Market.

GroceriesOnline Shopping

Misfits Market is an online grocery delivery service that started by selling "ugly" or surplus produce at a discount to reduce food waste, and has since expanded into a broader grocery box covering pantry staples, meat, and dairy shipped direct to subscribers' homes. There is no Misfits Market co-brand credit card, so a groceries-category card is the natural fit for these purchases, or a flat-rate cashback card if you would rather not track categories.

Picks without a tag earn at Misfits Market both in-store and online. Watch for theOnline onlytag — those bonuses only apply on misfitsmarket.com.

  1. #1
    Blue Cash Preferred
    American Express
    6% on groceries (up to $6,000/year, then 1%)
    U.S. supermarkets
    6%
  2. #2
    AAA Daily Advantage Visa Signature
    Comenity Capital Bank
    5% on groceries (up to $10,000/year, then 1%)
    Combined $500/year cash back cap with wholesale clubs and gas/EV-charging stations; 1% thereafter
    5%
  3. #3
    American Express Gold
    American Express
    4x points on groceries (up to $25,000/year, then 1%)
    4.8%4x points
  4. #4
    Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus
    Barclays
    4x points on groceries
    4.0%4x points
  5. #5
    Wyndham Rewards Earner Premier
    Barclays
    4x points on groceries
    Excludes Target and Walmart
    4.0%4x points
  6. #6
    Wells Fargo Choice Privileges Select Mastercard
    Wells Fargo
    5x points on groceries
    3.5%5x points
  7. #7
    AAA Travel Advantage Visa Signature
    Comenity Capital Bank
    3% on groceries
    3%
  8. #8
    Blue Cash Everyday
    American Express
    3% on groceries (up to $6,000/year, then 1%)
    U.S. supermarkets
    3%
  9. #9
    Capital One Savor Cash Rewards
    Capital One
    3% on groceries
    3%
  10. #10
    Capital One Savor Student Cash Rewards
    Capital One
    3% on groceries
    3%
  11. #11
    Capital One SavorOne Cash Rewards
    Capital One
    3% on groceries
    3%
  12. #12
    Citi Strata
    Citi
    3x points on groceries
    3.0%3x points
  13. #13
    Citi Strata Premier
    Citi
    3x points on groceries
    3.0%3x points
  14. #14
    Hilton Honors American Express Surpass
    American Express
    6x points on groceries
    U.S. supermarkets
    3.0%6x points
  15. #15
    Navy Federal More Rewards American Express
    Navy Federal
    3x points on groceries
    3.0%3x points
  16. #16
    USAA Cashback Rewards Plus
    USAA
    3% on groceries
    First $3,000/year
    3%
  17. #17
    Wyndham Rewards Earner
    Barclays
    3x points on groceries
    Excludes Target and Walmart; the 3x tier also covers eligible Wyndham Vacation Club purchases
    3.0%3x points
  18. #18
    Robinhood Gold
    Robinhood
    3% flat-rate cashback
    3%
  19. #19
    Bank of America Cash Rewards SecuredOnline onlyif you select it
    Bank of America
    3% on online shopping if you select it as a bonus category (up to $2,500/quarter, then 1%)
    3% in choice category (gas, online shopping, dining, travel, drugstores, home improvement); cap is combined with groceries/wholesale-club row
    3%
  20. #20
    Bank of America Customized Cash RewardsOnline onlyif you select it
    Bank of America
    3% on online shopping if you select it as a bonus category (up to $2,500/quarter, then 1%)
    3% in choice category (gas, online shopping, dining, travel, drugstores, home improvement); cap is combined with groceries/wholesale-club row
    3%

Related stores

Last updated September 14, 2026

Edit this pageReport an issue